Analysis of the Senate Tax Reform Bill – Part III: New Source Rules and Tax Reporting and Withholding Requirements

Early Saturday morning, the Senate voted 51-49 to approve a modified version of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (the “Senate Bill”). The Senate Bill differs from the House bill (discussed in an earlier series of posts here) passed last month in several respects, and a final negotiated bill will need to pass both chambers before the President can sign it into law. Given the difficulty of moving legislation through the Senate, it seems likely that any enacted legislation would likely be similar to the version passed by the House.

This post is the third in a series of three posts analyzing provisions of the Senate Bill. (Part I analyzes the elimination of the penalty for failing to maintain minimum essential coverage under the ACA and changes to equity and executive compensation.   Part II analyzes changes to deductions and exclusions for employee meals and other fringe benefits, changes to private retirement plan benefits, and a new paid leave credit.)

This post analyzes the new reporting and withholding requirements and source rules. Specifically, the Senate Bill would: (a) eliminate personal exemptions for income tax purposes but retain them for income tax withholding purposes; (b) require reporting for deductible amounts paid with respect to fines and penalties; (c) require reporting for certain life insurance transactions; (d) modify the reporting rules for Alaska Native Corporations; (e) modify the sourcing rule for sale of inventory items; (f) modify the sourcing rule for U.S. possessions; and (g) impose withholding under section 1446 for sale of an interest in a U.S. partnership by a foreign person that is treated as effectively connected income under new Code section 864(c)(8).

These changes generally would be effective after 2017, except as otherwise noted below.

Withholding Exemptions. The Senate Bill would raise the standard deduction and eliminate personal exemptions, which currently allow individuals to reduce their taxable income.  However, section 11041(c) of the Senate Bill would keep the value of the personal allowance in place for purposes of determining the correct amount of federal income tax withholding.

Reporting of Deductible Amounts Paid with Respect to Fines and Penalties. As we previously covered, section 13306(b) of the Senate Bill would adopt a new Code section 6050X requiring government agencies (or entities treated as government agencies) to report to the IRS and taxpayer on a new information return the amount of each settlement agreement or order entered into, where the aggregate amount required or directed to be paid or incurred exceeds a threshold ($600 in the statute, but subject to adjustment by Treasury).  The return must identify any amounts for restitution or remediation of property or correction of noncompliance, which are deductible, unlike fines and penalties paid under the agreement. These changes would generally apply to amounts paid or incurred on or after the date of enactment, except that the changes would not apply to binding orders or agreements entered into or subject to court approval before that date. The House bill did not include any similar provision.

Reporting of Certain Life Insurance Transactions. As we previously covered, section 13520 of the Senate Bill would also adopt a new Code section 6050Y that would create a new information reporting requirement for certain life insurance contract transactions. This includes: (a) a return filed and furnished by every person who acquires a life insurance contract or any interest in a life insurance contract in a “reportable policy sale”; (b) a return filed and furnished by each issuer of a life insurance contract upon notice of a transaction reported under (a); and (c) a return filed and furnished by every payor of “reportable death benefits.”  A “reportable policy sale” is generally the acquisition of an interest in a life insurance contract, directly or indirectly, if the acquirer has no substantial family, business, or financial relationship to the insured.  A “reportable death benefit” is an amount paid by reason of death of the insured under a life insurance contract that was transferred in a reportable policy sale.  The buyer must file the return required under (a) with the IRS and furnish copies of the return to the insurance company that issued the contract and the seller.  The insurance company that bears the risk with respect to a life insurance contract that receives a copy of a return required under (a) must file the return required under (b) with the IRS and furnish a copy of the return to the seller.  The payor insurance company must file the return required under (c) with the IRS and furnish a copy of the return to the payee.  The reporting requirements would apply for reportable death benefits paid and reportable policy sales after 2017. The House bill did not include any similar proposal.

Reporting Requirements of Alaska Native Corporations. Under current law, Alaska Native Corporations may deduct donations of cash or assets to “settlement trusts,” which are entities that manage Native lands. Section 13821(c) of the Senate Bill would modify the reporting requirements imposed on Native Corporations with respect to such deductions. Specifically, Native Corporations that have made contributions to a settlement trust and elected to deduct those contributions would be required to provide the settlement trust a statement regarding the election not later than January 31 of the calendar year after the calendar year in which the contribution was made. The statement would be required to include: (i) the amount of the contribution to which the election applies; (ii) whether the contribution was made in cash; (iii) for contributions of property other than cash, certain details about the property; (iv) the date of the contribution; and (v) any other information required by Treasury.

Sourcing Rule for Sale of Inventory Property. Under Code section 863(b), sales of inventory property produced in one jurisdiction and sold in another are currently sourced by allocating 50% of the sales income to one jurisdiction and 50% to the other.  Section 14304 of the Senate Bill would change this sourcing rule so that the entire amount would be sourced to the jurisdiction of production.

Sourcing Rule for U.S. Possessions. Section 14503 of the Senate Bill would change two provisions affecting the sourcing rules related to U.S. possessions.  First, Code section 937(b), which controls whether income of U.S. citizens and residents is treated as possession source income, generally provides that income treated as U.S. source or effectively connected with a U.S. trade or business is not treated as income from sources within a possession or effectively connected with a trade or business in that possession.  The Senate Bill would amend Code section 937(b)(2) so that only U.S. source or effectively connected income attributable to a U.S. office or fixed place of business is excluded from possession source income.  Second, the Senate Bill would amend Code section 865, which sets forth the sourcing rules for personal property sales, so that capital gains earned by a U.S. Virgin Islands resident would always be U.S. Virgin Islands source income.

Withholding on Gain from the Sale by Foreign Persons of Interests in Certain Partnerships. Section 13501 of the Senate bill would add a new Code section 864(c)(8) that treats a portion of the gain or loss on the sale or exchange of a partnership interest by a foreign person as effectively connected income if that partnership is engaged in a U.S. trade or business. Under the provision, if a foreign corporation or nonresident alien individual owns, directly or indirectly, an interest in a partnership engaged in a U.S. trade or business, a portion of the gain or loss on the sale or exchange of such interest is treated as effectively connected with the conduct of a U.S. trade or business to the extent such gain or loss does not exceed: (1) in the case of a gain, the portion of the partner’s distributive share of the amount of gain which would have been treated as effectively connected if the partnership had sold all of its assets at fair market value as of the date of the sale or exchange of the partnership interest (or zero, if no such deemed sale would have been effectively connected) or (2) in the case of a loss, the portion of the partner’s distributive share of the amount of loss on the deemed sale described in (1) which would have been effectively connected (or zero, if no such deemed sale would have been effectively connected).  The gain or loss treated as effectively connected under the provision is reduced by the amount so treated with respect to United States real property interests under section 897.

The Senate Bill would also amend Code section 1446 to impose a 10% withholding requirement on the amount of gain treated as effectively connected income under Code section 864(c)(8), similar to the existing rules under section 1445. Upon request by the transferor (generally, the seller) or the transferee (generally, the buyer), the Treasury may prescribe a reduce rate of withholding if the Secretary determines it is appropriate.  In addition, no withholding is required if a transferor furnish to the transferee an affidavit signed under penalty of perjury stating that the transferor is not a foreign person and providing the transferor’s U.S. TIN.  In the absence of such an affidavit (or if the transferee has actual knowledge that a provided affidavit is false or receives a notice from the transferor’s agent or transferee’s agent that such affidavit is false, similar to agent’s notice obligations under section 1445(d)), the transferee of the partnership interest is liable for satisfying the withholding obligation, but in the event that the transferee fails to withhold the required tax, the partnership must withhold an amount equal to the amount the transferee failed to withhold (plus interest) from distributions to the transferee.

The changes would generally be effective for sales and exchanges on or after November 27, 2017.