Tax Court Lacks Jurisdiction to Review IRS Employment Classification Determination

Post by
April 5, 2016

Today, the U.S. Tax Court held that it lacked jurisdiction to review a Form SS-8 determination that a father was an employee, not an independent contractor, of his son. In B G Painting, Inc. v. Commissioner, the son, a painting contractor, issued Forms 1099-MISC to his workers, including the father. The father filed a Form SS-8 (Determination of Worker Status for Purposes of Federal Employment Taxes and Income Tax Withholding), requesting that the IRS determine his employment status. In response, the IRS SS-8 Unit notified the parties that the father is the son’s “employee.” The son petitioned the court to review this determination.

The Tax Court held that it lacked statutory jurisdiction to review this determination because the Form SS-8 process is not an “examination.” Section 7436(a) of the Internal Revenue Code grants the Tax Court jurisdiction over employment status if “in connection with an audit of any person, there is an actual controversy involving a determination by the Secretary as part of an examination.” But the Form SS-8 process is not an “audit” or “examination”; rather, it is a voluntary compliance process involving no specific tax liabilities or assessments. Therefore, the Tax Court dismissed the case for lack of jurisdiction.

Once the IRS rules that an individual is an employee on the basis of a Form SS-8 submission, the employer has no right to appeal the determination. The IRS will send a follow-up letter to the employer asking whether the employer has filed Forms 941-x to pay the applicable FICA taxes based on the determination, whether the employer is eligible for Section 530 relief, and whether the employer has reasons for believing the IRS determination is incorrect. Given the obligation to provide health insurance to employees or face a potential tax penalty, the employer should expect an increased number of Form SS-8 submissions by independent contractors and increased focus on worker classification issues by the government.

If the employer fails to treat the individual as an employee following a Form SS-8 determination, the individual may file Form 8919 to report his or her share of FICA taxes. The same form can be used while a Form SS-8 is pending for the individual or if the individual was provided both a Form 1099-MISC and a Form W-2 and believes the income reported on the Form 1099 should have been included on Form W-2.